The Isolationist Theory and Why Walls Never Work
It was the year 221 BCE, The Chinese Empire decided that in order to protect itself from invaders, it would build the Great Wall of China. The Wall was vast, requiring constant repairs and a massive military presence. Guards and officials were sometimes bribed, allowing invaders to pass. The Wall was effective against small raiding parties, but Mongol leader Genghis Khan (13th century) and the Manchu invasion (17th century) showed that large, well-organized armies could simply go around, breach, or overpower the Wall.
Why Walls and Isolation Always Fail
Ultimately, if we want to know the future, knowing the past is always a good starting point. And history has taught us that walls—and isolation—always fail. Over time, the empire grows decadent and out of touch with neighboring nations, which always leads to its collapse.
What Does That Have to Do With Kids and Parenting Anyways?
I see a lot of Muslim parents building a wall around their kids—through a Muslim-only community, through limitations on what they’re exposed to. Now, that doesn’t mean we should sign up for Disney and let that run all day in the house, playing princess movies to our young daughters. But the middle is always the hardest to reach, and it is always where the greatest rewards are—if we are able to navigate as parents.
Expose to Reality, and Teach Alongside Them
The reason why walls fail is because they are the equivalent of a shield. Instead of helping the individual become strong enough to overpower an opponent, you are indirectly telling them they are too weak to face reality and should hold a shield all day long. Obviously, in any real fight, shields—or deflecting techniques—are part of the strategy, but they are never the only component a fighter has at their disposal.
Use Shields, but Help Them Build Strength and Techniques
If you teach them to recognize some of the faulty values in society, TV, or books, you are helping them learn to fight back. Learn to recognize the pattern, understand its values, and decide whether they want to internalize that or not. They are not passive anymore. They are active, aware, and deciding what they want to internalize.
The Longer Path
Yes, it means you have to spend time with your kid and not let them be brainwashed by TV. You can limit them to Muslim TV only, but they may be out of touch with friends who talk about other Western shows they don’t know about (isolation theory again). And one way or another, they will be exposed to content that isn’t Islamic.
And it is not just age that matters. We think of time as time. But in reality, it is the events in the seconds that make up time—not just time passing through itself. If you don’t help your kids build a thought mechanism, a mindset that allows them to interpret the data around them, then you are not helping them be strong. You are letting them stay weak and shielding them from the harsh realities of the world.
Walls always fail eventually.